Another “Nail in the Coffin” for Smoking in Strata

Smokers Unknowingly Breaching By-laws

A recent decision of the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) has recognised that even though a lot owner smokes inside their lot, they still may be in breach of the by-laws of the owners corporation and  leave themselves open to a penalty being imposed by NCAT.

Why? Because if the smoke leaves their apartment it will almost inevitably penetrate Common Property in one way or another.

A Recent Case…

This recent case illustrates that it is extraordinarily difficult for smokers to avoid breaching by-laws and why it’s important to have a well-drafted by-law if the owners corporation wishes to comprehensively deal with the issue.

Here we share the recent NCAT case article Smoking in Strata Apartments another “nail in the coffin”!

Also below, Warwick van Ede, Specialist Strata Lawyer talks with LookUpStrata on this very case and the many unanswered questions!


NCAT Smoking Common Property and Air Space Warwick van Ede Strata Lawyer

It’s definitely time to review your smoking by-law, or to implement one if you do not have one!


NEED A SMOKING BY-LAW OR TO REVIEW YOURS?

Contact Us

For all strata law advice including by-laws, building defects and levy collections contact our specialist NSW and Sydney strata lawyers here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.

Follow Us


Linkedin


Twitter


Envelope




Landmark Ruling and WIN for Any Owners Corporations!

Relevant for Any Owners Corporation with Combustible Cladding on Their Building.

On 18 October 2021, the NSW Supreme Court delivered a landmark judgment in the case of Taylor Construction Group Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan No. 92888 [2021] NSWSC 1315, confirming that biowood cladding is combustible cladding that poses a risk of fire spread between levels on the façade of an apartment building. Muellers represented the successful owners corporation in NCAT and also in the Supreme Court – a WIN for all owners corporations.

Senior Lawyer, Faiyaaz Shafiq, JS Mueller & Co Lawyers, said, “The outcome of the case represents a major win for owners corporations strengthening the basis for claims by owners corporations against builders and developers who have installed combustible cladding on their buildings.”

“I have no doubt it will see a marked shift in the way in which builders and developers respond to combustible cladding claims”, said Faiyaaz.

The owners corporation initially commenced proceedings in NCAT against the builder and developer seeking orders that biowood cladding installed on the façade of its building be replaced or compensation be paid to cover the cost to replace the cladding.

The owners corporation claimed that the cladding was combustible or created an undue risk of fire spread in breach of the statutory warranties under the Home Building Act 1989 because it did not comply with the Building Code of Australia and was not fit for its purpose.

NCAT ordered that the defective biowood cladding be rectified by the builder and developer. The builder/developer appealed NCAT’s findings to NCAT’s Appeal Panel which dismissed the appeal.

The builder/developer then appealed to the NSW Supreme Court.

The NSW Supreme Court on 18 October 2021 gave a comprehensive judgment dismissing the appeal. In doing so, the Court accepted the owners corporation’s arguments that:

  1. biowood cladding is combustible;
  2. there is a risk that fire will spread beyond the floor of origin because the material from which the biowood is made will support fire spread between the levels of the building;
  3. there was evidence from the fire safety engineer of the owners corporation that there is an undue risk of fire spreading due to the biowood;
  4. there was no evidence to support the contention of the builder/developer that a slower rate of fire spread does not present an undue risk in comparison with a higher rate of spread; and
  5. there was evidence that sprinklers or any other fire safety measure would have no relevance to external fire spread.

Furthermore, the Court also agreed with the owners corporation’s submission that combustible cladding is not fit for purpose which is one of the categories of the statutory warranties under the Home Building Act 1989.

The Court has reaffirmed the view that the fundamental fire safety requirement for a class 2 apartment building requires external walls to be non-combustible, and cladding installed in a multi-storey apartment building which does not comply with the BCA is not suitable for the purpose for which it is used.

The Court’s judgment confirms the view the owners corporation always held that biowood poses an unacceptable fire safety risk.

The Court’s judgment is a landmark ruling that is relevant to any owners corporation that has combustible cladding on its building.

The ruling strengthens the basis for claims by owners corporations against builders and developers who have installed combustible cladding on their buildings and should see a marked shift in the way in which builder and developers respond to those claims.

Note: Faiyaaz Shafiq of JS Mueller & Co Lawyers acted for the successful owners corporation and was assisted by barristers Tom Davie and Anita Power of Queen’s Square Chambers.

If you or your owners corporation require advice about combustible cladding, please contact our expert team now.

For all NSW strata legal advice including by-laws, building defects and levy collections contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.




Landmark Ruling – Upgrade that Balustrade!

In a landmark ruling, today the Appeal Panel of NCAT has ordered an owners corporation to upgrade a balustrade to comply with the Building Code of Australia.

This case marks the first time that an owners corporation has been ordered to upgrade an unsafe balustrade to achieve compliance with the Building Code of Australia.

The case cuts against the long held view that the provisions of the Building Code of Australia are not retrospective and that an owners corporation does not have to upgrade an unsafe balustrade to comply with the Code.

Here we share the full article Landmark NCAT Ruling – Upgrade that Balustrade

For all NSW strata legal advice including by-laws, building defects and levy collections contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.




By-laws which Regulate the Keeping of Pets!

The rules of the game relating to pets in strata buildings have changed.

Many owners corporations are not grappling with those new rules and trying to come to grips with them.

This has resulted in a shift away from by-laws that ban pets to by-laws which regulate the keeping of pets in strata buildings.

But do some of the rules that have been included in new pets by-laws go too far?

A recent and high profile NCAT case takes a closer look at that issue – By-laws that Regulate Pets.

For all NSW strata legal advice including by-laws, building defects and levy collections contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.




Must an Owners Corporation Repair Lot Property

In last week’s newsletter article, we reported on a recent NCAT case in which an owners corporation was ordered to repair damage to lot property caused by a common property roof leak.

Our article generated considerable interest. The NCAT decision begs the question: Is an owners corporation responsible for repairing lot property?

In this article, we take a closer look at that issue and consider whether the NCAT case we reported on last week (Mastellone v The Owners – Strata Plan No. 87110 [2021] NSWCATAP 188) was correctly decided.

Read the full article Is an Owners Corporation Responsible for Repairing Lot Property?

For all NSW strata legal advice including by-laws, building defects and levy collections contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.




Owners Corporation Told to Repair Lot Property by NCAT

There is a common misconception that an owners corporation is not responsible for repainting a water damaged ceiling in a lot or repairing consequential water damage to a lot that is caused by a common property defect.

In a recent case, NCAT held that:

  • an owners corporation is responsible for carrying out those repairs;
  • the common property memorandum does not exempt an owners corporation from having to perform those repairs.

Here we discuss the case and explain why an owners corporation is not exempt from repairing damage to lot property NCAT Orders Owners Corporation to Repair Lot Property

For all NSW strata legal advice including by-laws, building defects and levy collections contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.




NSW Combustible Cladding Taskforce – Who is Eligible?

The NSW Government has recently established a Cladding Taskforce known as ‘Project Remediate’.

This Taskforce will:

  • Identify residential buildings with potential combustible cladding issues
  • Address the use of non-compliant cladding materials with local councils

As of February 2021, 185,000 building records have been audited by the Taskforce with 4,127 buildings inspected.

It is important to note that not all cladding is dangerous. Fire + Rescue NSW (FRNSW) have been engaged to assist the Taskforce in determining building risk. Those buildings considered a higher risk will be further referred to consent authorities such as their Local Council or the Department of Planning, Industry and Environment (DPIE) for further investigation.

Register your interest in ‘Project Remediate’ here.

What is ‘Project Remediate’?

‘Project Remediate’ is a 3 year program designed to help remove combustible cladding from eligible residential buildings who will receive:

  • Interest free loans over a 10 year period with loan payments commencing after the completion of work
  • Assurance and project management services offering technical, risk and practical support to owners corporations and strata managers
  • A free 2-hour course on Project Remediate (free until 30 September 2021, following a fee of $140.00 will apply). This course is designed for strata managers and committee members of affected buildings to help them explain ‘Project Remediate’ to lot owners, to enable lot owners to make informed decisions.

Who is Eligible for ‘Project Remediate’?

To be eligible for ‘Project Remediate’ support, the building must be either:

  • A residential apartment building (Class 2) located in NSW approved by the Taskforce to have a high-risk combustible cladding façade which requires remediation
  • A multi-use building which has part commercial/residential located in NSW approved by the Taskforce to have a high-risk combustible cladding façade which requires remediation

Do you need More Information on ‘Project Remediate’?

For more specific information please visit:

Do You Need Further Assistance with Combustible Cladding Issues?

Combustible cladding (and building defects) is a complex area of the law.

The team at JS Mueller & Co Lawyers has unparalleled knowledge and experience dealing with many cases in this complex area of the law.

JS Mueller & Co Lawyers published flammable cladding cases:

If you would like assistance with flammable cladding (and/or building defect) issues, please contact us now, we are here to help you.




Who is Responsible for Mould in Strata Living?

As winter fast approaches lot owners and tenants ‘cosy up’ their apartment environments with heat creating condensation (moisture) and reduced ventilation – a damp environment that mould loves to thrive in.

Rain during the winter months can also contribute to the increased mould growth in strata buildings and may cause dangerous health issues for owners and tenants as they’re more likely to stay indoors.

Who is responsible for mould in a strata property?

It depends on the location of the mould, and what initially caused the mould to develop. Sounds simple, but the challenge is to work out who organises and pays for the problem to be fixed.

In this article we look at:

  1. What is mould?
  2. What are the harmful effects mould can have on your health?
  3. What are the causes of mould in strata living?
  4. Who pays for the mould to be fixed in strata living?

1. What is mould?

Mould is a type of fungi that produces tiny spores which settle on indoor and outdoor surfaces. When the mould spores land on a damp or wet spot, they need a certain temperature to thrive and survive, they then begin to grow and digest the surface where they’ve landed.

Mould can destroy building materials, furnishings and cause serious health problems to people.

2. Is Mould Harmful to your Health?

Airborne mould spores are commonly found in both indoor and outdoor environments and have the potential to cause health problems as they can easily be inhaled.

Inhaling mould spores can have harmful effects on health in children and the elderly, asthmatics, and people with compromised immune systems. It can cause throat, eye and nose irritations, breathing problems and allergic reactions. Some mould can even have more serious health effects and cause chronic, obstructive, or allergic lung diseases.

Mould can also destroy clothing and household items such as mattresses and other furniture which can also cause health issues.

3. What are the Causes of Mould in Strata Apartments?

In strata apartments, mould typically grows indoor in wet or moist areas lacking adequate ventilation, including walls, wallpaper, ceilings, bathroom tiles, carpets (especially with jute backing) and insulation material such as cardboard and wood.

Some common mould problems in strata apartments include:

  • Lack of adequate waterproofing allowing water to leak inside an apartment
  • Burst pipes or water leaks coming from an apartment above
  • Condensation in winter on walls/windows from temperature differences between heated interiors and cold exteriors
  • High levels of humidity in summer and temperature differences of cold interiors and heated exteriors
  • Condensation from hot showers causing mould on bathroom walls and ceilings, especially if there is no exhaust fan and/or ventilation
  • Windows closed all day with lack of adequate air flow
  • Strata blocks that are in shade all day and receive no or little sun

4. Who is Responsible for Mould in Strata?

 
Property Managers and Landlords

In a rental apartment situation, the  landlord is normally responsible for fixing the mould problem as the landlord is responsible for ensuring their tenant a healthy, mould-free environment.

However, if the landlord can show the mould is the result of the tenant’s inactions such as not using exhaust fans or not opening windows/doors for airflow, the tenant may be liable to compensate the landlord for damage.

Strata Managers and Owners Corporations

In strata title properties the person responsible will depend on where the mould is located and what is causing it, which can sometimes be challenging.

Generally, the apartment owner is responsible for removing the mould inside the apartment. However, if there is a defect in the common property that is the cause of the mould, such as a leaking common property pipe, the owners corporation would be responsible for fixing that defect.

Common Property
Common property boundaries of an apartment are generally defined by the floor surface and boundary walls. If mould is located outside of these boundaries the owners corporation is responsible for repairs and mould remediation costs. If the cause of the mould is within these boundaries the lot owner is responsible for repairs and costs.

Strata mould problems are often challenging to solve. In these more challenging cases it is often a good idea to engage with a strata lawyer to help resolve the issue,  and to work out who is responsible for fixing the problem, especially if it involves health issues.


Adrian Mueller Partner JS Mueller & Co Lawyers specialising in Strata Law

Adrian Mueller I BCOM LLB FACCAL I Partner

Since 2002 Adrian has specialised almost exclusively in the area of strata law. His knowledge of, and experience in strata law is second to none. He is the youngest person to have been admitted as a Fellow of the ACSL, the peak body for strata lawyers in Australia. Profile I Linked

Contact Us

For all strata law advice including by-laws, building defects and levy collections contact our specialist NSW and Sydney strata lawyers here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.




Gone are the Days of Smoking Freely!

‘Smoke Drift’ in Strata Blocks

In Australia, most apartment blocks, old or new have banned smoking in common areas such as hallways, common living spaces, outdoor communal areas and more.

In some states, strata committees have completely banned smoking in all areas of apartments by introducing smoke free by-laws.

And… fast becoming a reality in strata living is a total ban with smoke free apartment blocks.

In recent times second hand smoke has become a major health concern in Strata blocks with organisations such as the Cancer Council getting behind the move.

With this fight against smoke drift and new precedents being set landlords, owners corporations and strata managers need to carefully consider what kind of smoking by-laws will be implemented in their strata blocks. Here we outline three options:

1. Unrestricted Smoking By-law

Many older strata blocks may have unrestricted smoking as a default by-law unaware that they are leaving themselves in a vulnerable position. They should consider reviewing their by-laws to keep up with the latest health concerns and legalities.

2. Limited Smoking By-law

A ‘middle ground’ by-law may limit lot owners and tenants to only smoking within their apartment but not in common areas. However, there have been a number of cases where fines of up to $11,000 have been issued due to second hand smoke creating health issues.

3. Complete Smoking Ban By-law

Only some states currently allow a complete smoking ban. A complete ban includes all areas of apartment blocks, including individual apartments, balconies and common areas.

Ensure Your ‘Smoke Drift’ By-laws are Up to Date

If smoking is a problem in a strata building, the owners corporation should make a by-law prohibiting smoking. This type of by-law is simple to prepare and enforce. Orders can be obtained to stop residents smoking and put an end to second hand smoke drift. It’s also important to note that smoke drift can also be caused by BBQ’s.

Support for smoke-free multiunit living is high particularly among people living with children. It is only a matter of time before most strata buildings go smoke free.


DO YOU NEED YOUR ‘SMOKE DRIFT’ BY-LAW CHECKED?

For all NSW strata legal advice including by-laws, building defects and levy collections contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.




Considering Mediation – Get the Right Advice!

How should your owners corporation deal with a request from a lot owner to attend at Mediation?

Mediation is an important part of the dispute resolution processes for strata schemes pursuant to the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015.

A recent decision of the Appeal Panel of NCAT  has underlined the need for agreements reached at Mediation to be sufficiently certain if they are to be capable of being enforced under the strata legislation.

This in turn raises questions about how owners corporations should approach Mediation, particularly the most common form of Mediation for strata matters, under the auspices of Fair Trading NSW.

In this recent case we explain how getting the wrong advice can stop you from enforcement.

Where ever possible an owners corporation should take the following steps Mediation and the Right Advice.

For all NSW strata legal including by-laws, building defect and levy collection advice contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.